Ambleside Schools International Articles

Browse more Ambleside Schools International Resources.

How AI Disengages, Diminishes, and Substitutes for Learning with God

Artificial Intelligence (AI) can leave users with diminished brain capacity, reduced brain connectivity, reduced brain activity, poorer memory retention, decreased cognitive abilities, and, for some people, a loss of skills (as reported by APA, NIMH, and other studies). In short, when we farm out our thinking, our capacity diminishes.

 

AI places a screen between us and whatever we study. Screens increase our sense of disengagement. Even watching our children through a camera screen while recording their events makes us forget the event more quickly. Parents feel less connected. Screens disrupt the fast, nonverbal communication that creates understanding. We all know what it is like to look at someone who is looking at their phone screen. AI places its screen between us and every topic we bring to it. We become more disengaged.

 

Screens also make us more gullible. Our brains automatically question what people say to decide whether to believe it. The same critical response is not produced by screens the way it is by faces. Our judgment may diminish. We may not notice that AI is telling us what it thinks we want to hear by predicting what others would tell us, as we will see in a moment. We should be quite careful with anything that diminishes us. Using AI 1) reduces what the brain must do and 2) reduces our engagement with life. We can manage these two problems, although most people will not.

 

One way that AI can diminish us might not be obvious. This risk lies in the very nature of what AI does: solve problems. Western culture values problem solving. An AI agent converts us (and whatever questions we bring) into problems to solve. AI agents must first solve what we want to hear. AI is built to try and deliver what we want to hear. We easily let ourselves be the problem.

 

The second problem for AI is sorting through everything it has read and collected to predict what we want to hear. It gathers the answer from what AI has read of people’s wisdom and folly. Unfortunately, much of what AI now reads was written by AI. Most current AI systems are built using a Large Language Model. To develop “intelligence,” the computer is asked to read everything available and predict what will come next. It examines everything stored in computers and the internet, then predicts the next word or idea. When AI can guess what comes next, it is considered intelligent.

 

When we ask AI agents a question, AI combines what its computer resources predict people would say next. In one way, AI is telling us what we want to hear. In another way, AI is telling us what the world would tell us.

 

Let’s say my chainsaw doesn’t start, and I ask AI. It predicts I want to hear how to start the chainsaw. That is helpful. AI tells me what the people who talk about chainsaws say about saws that don’t start. This is helpful, but it may be wrong, damaging, or dangerous. This process works fairly well because I am trying to solve a problem. I will check AI with my judgment, experience, and a real-world chainsaw. The real world provides a safeguard.

 

If I ask AI about a person, place, or thing, AI converts them all into problems to solve. Education, child-raising, knowing God, finding a mate, and healthy living become problems. Finding hacks on the internet to fix our spiritual lives, or improve relationships with loved ones, or with God, is another way we see others as problems. AI only knows problems and how to solve them. Approaching life as a problem to solve diminishes people and God in our thinking.

 

Most of life is NOT a problem to be solved. God and God’s world represent opportunities, not problems. Opportunities develop our minds, identities, and relationships. We grow in wisdom and maturity. Discovering life, God and creation comes through thinking with God about everything we see – not as problems but as possibilities. Through this interaction we discover that we, others and God all have special identities. A self is not a problem. Selves create relationships, love, joy, togetherness, awe, discovery, and gratitude. God’s identity even extends to creation. These things are not problems.

 

The problem we really need to solve involves finding our true identities. People have very little that is more important than building a real self capable of lasting relationships. AI cannot solve our identity problem. AI does not have an enduring identity. At any moment, AI may have 1000s of different selves that appear and disappear with each agent AI creates.

 

Agents cannot share our sufferings and build character by saying what we want to hear or what the world would say. What does God think of: 1) being told what we want to hear and 2) listening to what the whole world tells us? Both are very dangerous sources of guidance. “Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed” is the message from St. Paul. (Romans 12:2) Our thinking should be done in harmony with God, where the potential for transforming thinking can be found. St. Paul tells us, “For the time will come when people will not tolerate sound doctrine, but according to their own desires, will multiply teachers for themselves because they have an itch to hear what they want to hear.” (2 Timothy 4:3)

 

What God thinks about our identities, the things that God has prepared for those who love him, has not entered in the human imagination. Yet these thoughts are being revealed to those who love God and think with him. (1 Corinthians 2:9-10) In thinking with God, we are elevated. We see things that no one has imagined or written. Our true identities become opportunities to explore. We are God’s agents, engaging the real world and expressing what God is thinking here and now. Perhaps our identities will solve problems, but that is not what we are created to be. Problem solving does not elevate us or others.

 

Life is not a problem to solve. Let us not become problems to solve, yield to computer groupthink, allow people to confine our identities, or restrict our mental capacities. Thinking with God includes all of life. Thinking with God is worthy work.

 

Dr. E James Wilder

PHD, Clinical Psychology, MA Theology,

Fuller Theological Seminary

Training Leaders and Counselors on Five Continents